You're viewing part of a thread.
-
Is it not dehumanizing to call veterans psychotic? Seems a bit like kicking someone while they're down. The military broke them enough, the last things veterans need is to be mocked, dehumanized and treated like creeps.
-
first of all, i didn't call them psychotic. read it again.
second of all, you literally say they're broken. i don't know what to tell you.
and finally, fuck veterans, like I give a shit how they want to be treated. maybe they shouldn't thought of that before they volunteered to kill or help kill as many brown kids as they can. unless they were drafted or something then they get a pass. sort of.
-
None of the veterans I know killed any brown kids. The people we shot were generally either shooting at us, or had just set off an IED with a car battery. Most of our interactions with kids involved someone getting in trouble for giving away MREs to the kids that would walk up to the vehicle.
-
wow #notallinvaders. i said kill or help kill. they fall into the second category. they still volunteered for unjust, illegal wars, unless you're talking about WW2 or something... the US had no right to be in any foreign country in the last few decades.
-
No one I fought with was helping kill brown kids either. You could argue that we were indirectly helping, since we were fighting for a country that was also sometimes bombing areas with civilians. If that's how you would like to approach this, then everyone helped.
If you've worked in retail then you've sold goods to soldiers, if you work in agriculture then you've fed them, and if you're a teacher then you educated them. Some small fraction of those soldiers went on to bomb kids somewhere.
If you want to criticize the US policy of invading other countries on a pretext and then propping up governments that do what we want, go ahead. I'm right there with you. If you want to live in a fantasy where all soldiers are merciless baby-killers, I guess you can do that, but that's where we part ways.
Soldiers are individuals, and they sign up for all sorts of reasons. A very common reason is an education that gives them a better shot at a high paying job so that they can care for their family or start one. Is it fucked that people feel the need to do that? Sure. Would it be great if there was a straight forward way for a person with no resources to get an education and a better job? Yes.
But currently, we're in an environment where risking your life to fight for your country in an unjust war is the best option some people have. And pretending that the reason they do it is because they're Bad People doesn't help solve the problem.
-
-
-
males and females is still psychotic if you’re not specifically talking science like biology, statistics, etc.
I don't think the veterans are doing it just when talking about science. So that'd mean it would be psychotic, according to you. At least that's how I understood what you wrote.
-
dehumanization is part of military
as the commenter said, they say it because it's drilled into them. but it's drilled into them because it's dehumanizing. so yes, it is psychotic.
saying an action is psychotic is not the same as saying people who do an action are psychotic. that's the difference between saying "you're being silly" and "you're a silly person".
-
I'm just commenting that they said they didn't call them psychotic but also from the first message and the line you quoted it sounds like they are calling them psychotic.
males and females is still psychotic if you’re not specifically talking science like biology, statistics, etc.
dehumanization is part of military
first of all, i didn’t call them psychotic. read it again.
I'm not trying to take part in the rest of the argument, it just confused me a bit
-
-
-
-
There’s a difference between the people who have served and the insane asylum they were subjected to. There are plenty of things that meat factory does to people that shouldn’t be replicated in society, and this is the least of them.
-
Those are not complete sentences or even a sort of expression of any coherent potential intent of expression. Go back to English class and fix your sentences, please.
-
-