Privacy @lemmy.ml Gordon_F @lemmy.ml 3d ago

Private videoconferencing ?

Hi,

I'm looking for a E2EE and decentralized (or self hosted) videoconferencing that would have the following feature

video or voice-only call
share screen
files transfer (optional)
text chat

( all of it E2EE )

I'm considering Jitsi meet, that seem the meet those requirements

Do you know better alternatives or do you have remarks about Jitsi ?

Thanks.

21 comments

We used Jitsi quite a bit during Covid, I was very happy with it, and I don't remember any complaints from other people.
Give MiroTalk a try. Can be self-hosted and just like Jitsi, no need to install anything, it's all in-browser. Has all the features you're asking for.

https://github.com/miroslavpejic85/mirotalk

If you want to test drive it:

https://p2p.mirotalk.com/
If I remember correctly, Jitsi is not E2EE by default. You need to set it up manually.

Jami on the other hand, is E2EE by default and decentralized (if I'm not mistaken).
- E2EE by default and decentralized (if I’m not mistaken)
  
  You are not mistaken, Jami is both.
I personally haven't used it yet but I believe you can do all this with Matrix (choose your client - probably Element).
- Matrix currently just uses jitsi for group video calls. Native functionality is in development.
  
  It's in beta, but it's already quite usable. You can try it without account on a public instance e.g. at call.element.io
  
  Why did I think that changed with 2.0? Another commenter identified this. Element has native call now.
It's already been mentioned, but I'll throw in for Jitsi. I believe it can also be self-hosted.
Maybe Signal since they have group call links now ?
- "decentralized or self-hosted"
  
  Love Signal, but doesnt meet the criteria.
Jami is also an option
- I've never got Jami to actually work.
Adding onto what's already on the thread, you can try look at the newer Element Call, which is an implementation of Matrix's native calls.
I've been using it a bit recently, since Jitsi seems to have stopped working reliably for me (to be frank, I've not put much effort into debugging it yet). It works well, but it's still early stage, lacking some features Jitsi has. If that one works for you, I recommend you stick to it.
Self hosted XMPP
never heard of jitsi, but looks pretty legit from what you shared!
You're probably going to end up on Jitsi meet, but I'm also going to drop a recommendation for bigbluebutton.

I recently noticed that it was integrated into the open source Learning-Management-System Canvas, which every school I have gone to so far uses.

Although bigbluebutton doesn't seem to explicitly support e2ee (but maybe this counts for something), if you are already using Canvas, BigBlueButton definitely worth looking at.

I really, really wish people at my school would use the integrated bigbluebutton instead of using zoom, especially given I've seen people occasionally have issues with authentication for zoom, but all of that stuff is handled with bigbluebutton because it's fully browser based and integrated into Canvas.
It’s tangential, but Mumble is still good for voice only chat. Rarely do we find video to be useful or necessary with a lot of collaborative tools showing multiple cursors per users & programs like Upterm that allow sharing a terminal session.
Jitsi was a pain for me to get working the way I needed it, but I have to say I'm a fan so far. I haven't used it too much yet (mainly just testing with myself from various networks/devices), but from what I can tell it'll work for my use (replacing Google Meet for my family chat uses).
OpenTalk is a more modern option.

21 comments