Is there any front end YouTube that can allow me to still comment?
Is there any front end YouTube that can allow me to still comment?
Probably a dumb question, thanks for all the front end responses, I’ve been watching using them but want to engage. I really don’t want to keep using Google though!
Or should I just get used to not engaging or maybe bringing videos here and commenting if they’re that interesting.
-
No because all comments require being logged into a google account.
-
The platform is owned by Google. By using YouTube in any way, watching, liking, subscribing, commenting, searching, clicking, all of it, you're "using Google".
So, the answer is that you cannot use YouTube and not use Google.
If Google is broken up, that might change, but I'm not sure if that will ever happen, what form that might take or if it would ever happen at all.
-
Not really what I’m asking, but yes I get YouTube is Google.
-
i think their point is if you want to comment make a google account and comment.. or dont.
personally, it boggles the mind why anyone would want to do that.
-
-
youtube costs too much money to handle by medium/large sized company
-
-
Or should I just get used to not engaging or maybe bringing videos here
Yes. Do that. It helps Lemmy grow and helps G shrink.
-
You can use the Polycentric protocol on Grayjay, though I doubt any creators actually read it.
-
Thanks! Do others read it at least? lol I’ll have to look this up, don’t know either of those things
-
Judging from the last time I looked at their comment platform, it had the feeling that the only users of it were ones that were banned from Youtube because of the toxic shit they're wanting to post so I mean, I guess, but it's not the experience you're wanting, probably.
-
-
-
No, not really. Commenting requires you do be signed in which means privacy is out the Window.
Why do you want to comment? Maybe start watching peertube?
-
The closest that you can get is using something like Grayjay, where they have their own social media system, but your comments will only be interactable to other people using Grayjay.
-
Psst. Nobody really cares about YouTube comments. You are writing to a black hole of nothingness.
-
They are the most toxic and hateful comments I have ever seen.
-
-
Other responses have covered the “not without being logged into Google” part, so I’ll just add that if you don’t care about being logged into Google and the thing you want from a front end is Sponsor Block, then yes: YouTube in a browser with the Sponsor Block extension. On Android, the YouTube app w/ Revanced accomplishes the same thing.
-
At one time there were browser extensions that allowed you to comment on any web page and allowed other extension users to see your comments.
The comments were hosted through the extension and not on the pages themselves.
Something like that would be possible but I don’t know anyone offering it now. I presume no one wants to moderate that.